Showing posts with label commercialization of residential property. Show all posts
Showing posts with label commercialization of residential property. Show all posts

Saturday, March 29, 2014

Affordability, Part 2: Opportunity Costs and "Highest and Best Use"

One reason I like to do outreach on zoning issues is that I learn a lot from these forums. Each neighborhood has its own set of development issues -- some are unique; others are variations on common themes or harbingers of things to come. And every neighborhood has a wealth of local knowledge, eagerly shared by people who have watched and analyzed what's been going on around them. The social scientist in me -- I'm a former college professor with an interdisciplinary background in law and society -- is fascinated by the variety of ways in which the same rules play out differently across the city.

This post was inspired by Ward 1, where "condo-ization" puts single-family housing stock and neighborhoods at risk.

"Single-family homes" can (and do) accommodate a variety of different types of households -- nuclear families with or without kids, multi-generational families, groups of roommates, boarders, live-in caregivers, and renters of accessory units. Over the course of its lifespan, the same house may move fluidly between these various types of living arrangements.

What makes condo-ization problematic is that, once a property ceases to have a single owner, this fluidity is lost. Suddenly, even though it's still one building, the house is no longer one property. And finding a single owner who is willing and able to re-acquire all the units post-conversion (probably over time and with the possibility of holdouts) seems unlikely.

In neighborhoods like Mount Pleasant and Lanier Heights, residents have seen that condo-ization is pushing housing costs up -- not down. Rent in a group house is affordable to recent college grads and other newcomers who wouldn't have the financial means to live in the same house if it were divided into condos selling for upwards of $500,000 each. Increasingly, condo conversions are effectively pricing older homes in these communities out of the single-family market. They're also changing the look and scale of historic rowhouse neighborhoods by incentivizing pop-ups and pop-outs.

In general, the most affordable housing is in older buildings. Which means that when older residential buildings get torn down and replaced by newer residential buildings, the net result is likely to be increased housing costs. Basically, it only makes sense to tear one building down and build another to serve the same function if the replacement building will produce substantially more income. When bigger buildings replace smaller buildings, part of the increase in income comes from the fact that there are more units to sell or rent, but it's also the case that a new building (or unit) will most likely command a higher rent or sales price than an older one -- in part, just because it's new but also because, from a development perspective, projects that command higher rents are more attractive, especially in places where land values and existing properties haven't yet realized the full market potential of the area. That's why seemingly every new multifamily project in DC is a"luxury" condo or apartment building featuring lots of smaller units.

Subdivision is a more ambiguous phenomenon than teardowns -- it can happen for a variety of reasons (e.g. if there's no market for single-family homes of a particular size in a particular area) and its economic consequences may vary. In areas where single-family homes are scarce and in high demand, downzoning (and/or other restrictions) may be necessary to preserve existing housing stock. In the past, some rowhouse neighborhoods relied on historic designation to protect neighborhood scale and character. But, increasingly, historic preservation hasn't proven sufficient -- which, presumably, is one reason why Georgetown requested (and was granted) a reduction in allowable building heights (from 40 to 35 feet in rowhouse zones) in the ZRR.


There's a broader issue here -- and it's not limited to historic neighborhoods or areas, like Lanier Place, where the existing zoning is out-of-sync with the built environment. In general, once OP starts loosening zone definitions, new ways to use land are put in competition with existing uses. And where the existing uses are single-family homes, those will quickly cease to be the "highest and best" (i.e. most lucrative) use of the property. So the conversions begin -- and, as Ward 1 residents have pointed out, some of those conversions will not be reversible.

If we value single-family housing (or if we want garden apartments, or if we want neighborhood-serving retail, or any other relatively small-scale type of development), then we need to have restrictive zoning that is consistently enforced. Zoning that restricts the use of some parcels to single-family housing (or to some other specific use) doesn't have to mean suburbanization -- different types of zones can be located in close proximity to each other in the same neighborhood. The issue is limiting the range of potential uses in competition for the same property, so that market forces don't overwhelm desired types of development.  Which, after all, is the raison d'etre of planning and zoning.  








Wednesday, March 19, 2014

How the ZRR would affect public input regarding development decisions

Under DC’s current zoning code, most development decisions fall into one of three categories – those that are matter of right, those that require special exceptions, and those that require variances.

Matter-of-right decisions are made unilaterally by the property owner.  As long as the owner’s project falls within the legally-established parameters of the zone – the building fits within the zoning envelope, its location on the lot is consistent with yard and setback requirements, the use is expressly authorized – then no public input or notice is involved.

Other decisions require permission.  In each zone, the code lays out some restrictions that may be waived by special exception and provides standards (which can be generic or specific) that must be met to justify such a waiver.  It also provides a Board of Zoning Adjustment (BZA) process for evaluating whether (and/or how) the project meets those standards.  This process gives neighbors advance notice of the project, involves a public hearing in which they can testify, and is one in which ANC input, as expressed through an official resolution, must be accorded “great weight.”* Typically, what happens in a special exception case is that the BZA listens to all parties and helps to craft a set of project-specific conditions that will enable it to grant the owner’s request without sacrificing the interests of neighboring property-owners.  It’s important to remember (and the ZRR rhetoric sometimes obscures the fact that) the special exception process is designed to facilitate -- not prohibit -- zoning relief.  Special exceptions are almost always approved.  (Which doesn’t mean that the process is pointless.  At a minimum, the special exception process gives property owners a powerful incentive to talk through their plans with their immediate neighbors, hear their concerns, and try to reach mutually-agreeable solutions.)

While the norm in special exception cases is that permission will be granted (subject to conditions), the norm in variance cases is that permission will be denied.  That’s because variances allow a type of development the zone is attempting to prohibit -- which is why the standard for granting a variance is so high.   A variance may be granted only when some peculiar attribute of the property creates a situation in which compliance with the zoning requirement would create an exceptional and undue hardship for the owner and when waiver of the requirement would not be detrimental to others or inconsistent with the intent and purpose of the Zoning Regulations.  Because variances are granted based on unique circumstances, they aren't meant to serve as precedents for other sites or projects.

There are also a few planning processes/tools that foster public input – most notably, PUDs, campus plans, and overlays.   In theory, the planned unit development (PUD) process was designed for larger development projects.  PUDs typically involve the simultaneous waiver of multiple zoning restrictions and often include project-specific upzoning requests (“map amendments”).  The PUD process also requires notice and public hearings, but the decisionmaker in PUDs is the Zoning Commission (ZC) rather than the BZA.  Once again, this is a process in which ANC resolutions are given great weight
  
Overlays, which involve localized modifications of generic zoning to achieve specific neighborhood objectives (e.g. to protect trees and slopes, or to prevent the conversion of residential property to other uses, or to create a neighborhood-serving retail district), have been eliminated in the ZRR.  The provisions of existing overlays have been (somewhat ineptly) incorporated into the new code as distinctive zones, but it appears as if the opportunity to create new overlays has been eliminated.  Since overlays are one of the most powerful ways neighborhoods have found to solve local problems and to preserve the characteristics they value, their elimination would represent a major loss of public input into the planning process.   Under the current code, overlays have generally been initiated by neighborhoods and adopted by the Zoning Commission as text amendments to the zoning regulations.
 
To give you a sense of how the ZRR would affect the range of decisions in which ANCs, neighborhood associations, and local residents have the opportunity to provide input, I’ve made a chart that looks at various development requests that currently trigger a public process and contrasted how those decisions are made now with how they would be made if the ZRR were adopted.

DEVELOPMENT REQUEST
CURRENT
PROCESS

ZRR PROPOSAL
Residential development of substandard-size lot
variance
matter of right
Conversion of a single-family home into an apartment house in an R-5-A zone

special exception

matter of right
Rental apartment
located within a home
special exception
matter of right
Rental apartment
located in a garage or other outbuilding


variance
matter of right for pre-existing building;
or
special exception for new or enlarged building
Two-story garage or other outbuilding
variance
matter of right
Home occupation located in a garage
variance
matter of right
Home occupation and rental apartment on the same residential lot

special exception

matter of right
Habitable penthouse atop a single family home



variance
matter of right if
  • no more than 10 feet tall
  • no more than 1/3 of the roof's footprint
  • set back from the street/alley by a distance equal to its height and from non-abutting side walls by a distance equal to 1/2 its height
Retail or service business on a residential lot
grandfathered
non-conforming
use
or
variance
matter of right if
  •  home occupation or
  • food store on a corner lot in a rowhouse zone
  • replacing an existing store
special exception for retail, general service, arts creation, or eating & drinking establishment use on a corner lot or in an historically non-residential building in a rowhouse zone
Use not authorized in the relevant zone
variance
approval of the Zoning Administrator**
Reduction of on-site parking requirements near transit
25% reduction = matter of right if building is
non-residential,
located within 800 feet of a Metrorail station entrance, and not within 800 feet of a residential zone

> 25% reduction = special exception (for a non-residential building), variance (residential building), or PUD process
50% reduction = matter of right for any type of building to be constructed in an apartment or mixed use zone on a site that is within 1320 feet of a major bus route or 2640 feet of a Metro rail station.

  



> 50% reduction = special exception
Elimination of on-site parking requirements


variance or
PUD process
matter of right if      
  • downtown (any use) or 
  •  single-family home without alley access or 
  •  multifamily building with fewer than 6 units
Elimination of restrictions on FAR in C-3-C zones newly-defined as part of downtown


PUD process
matter of right, if development is residential
or
by purchasing density credits from a developer-controlled market
  [[N.B.:  This chart is a work in progress.  It isn't an exhaustive list -- just changes I've run across thus far.  And because I've never been an ANC Commissioner, I'm not familiar with the range of development cases they routinely encounter (although clearly it varies from Commission to Commission).  If you find any errors, want to suggest any additions, or wonder whether the rules regarding a type of development decision I haven't discussed are being changed, please feel free to email me -- smithhemb@aol.com -- and let me know.  I'll be continually updating the chart, so check back here for the most up-to-date version before citing, circulating, or relying on the chart.]]

One final point.  The ZRR proposes a new category – “conditional matter-of-right.”  On one level, matter-of-right is always conditional – e.g. you can build whatever structure you want as long as it fits within the parameters of the zoning.   So it doesn’t really seem like a distinct category – and it certainly isn’t one that involves any public process.   It’s still matter-of-right.

On another level, it’s worth pointing out that the “conditions” associated with this new variation of matter-of-right are not analogous to the conditions imposed through a special exception.   Here are three crucial differences:

(1) In a special exception proceeding, neighbors are notified, plans are made public, and conditions are discussed and negotiated prior to the requested project being built. Objections can be made (and solutions or compromises hammered out) before development begins. With conditional matter-of-right, the property owner builds the project without neighborhood input. The neighbors are presented with a fait accompli and the logical/likely response to their objections will be “so sue me.”

(2) In the conditional matter-of-right scenario, nothing is really contingent upon the conditions being met. By contrast, in a special exception proceeding, permission to build and/or operate a facility is conditioned on compliance. Failure to seek a special exception or to comply with the terms on which one has been granted can lead to denials of building permits, refusals or revocations of certificates of occupancy, or even the dismantling of structures that are out of compliance.

(3) The BZA, which is a deliberative tribunal, grants special exceptions. There's a transparent public process that leaves a clear paper trail -- BZA (and ZC) orders spelling out conditions can be easily accessed online and are searchable by location (square and lot number).  By contrast, to the extent that there’s any enforcement of matter-of-right conditions, that job would be left to DCRA -- a notoriously unreliable administrative agency whose decisionmaking tends to be opaque.  If you're dealing with DCRA, answers to questions like who made a decision, why, and based on what information are probably only available through FOIA requests or litigation.  (And, for what it's worth, when I testified at DCRA's budget hearing last year, neither the agency nor the Council's Committee Chair seemed to have any sense that changes in the zoning regulations could lead to a major increase in DCRA's workload.)

To me, the bottom line here is that, at a point where we're moving toward increased density, intensity, and diversity of land use, we're also losing opportunities for meaningful public input on development decisions that will significantly affect the character of our neighborhoods and our city.



*The BZA need not follow the ANC’s recommendations, but it must respond, in writing, to any relevant concerns raised by an ANC resolution.  In other words, great weight doesn't involve deference to neighborhood opinion; its function is simply to ensure that agencies listen to -- and actively consider -- the officially-expressed preferences and interests of the communities that will be most directly affected by their decisions.

** The Zoning Administrator (ZA) is a DCRA employee.  The ZA's job is to verify compliance before signing off on permits.  No hearing (or notice) is required prior to the decision of the ZA and the only paper trail is the permit itself.  

Wednesday, March 12, 2014

We've Got Issues...

While participating in public hearings and outreach efforts, I've been keeping a running list of issues various residents and neighborhoods have with the proposed new zoning code.  Here's the current version.

 

Major omissions:

The proposed new code fails to:


·        Address the issue of housing affordability and fix what’s broken in the current inclusionary zoning provisions.

·        Implement neighborhood conservation measures – e.g. to prevent pop-ups, dig outs, McMansions, conversion of housing stock to other uses, condo-ization of houses, out-of-scale development, etc. or to provide more effective buffering between zones with significantly different scale, uses, or intensities of use.  Increasingly, a neighborhood that is not protected by historic preservation will not be protected at all.  And historic preservation itself is becoming less protective than it used to be.

·        Incentivize development in areas that have suffered from disinvestment.

·        Apply the Green Area Ratio and affordable housing requirements to the newly expanded downtown. Analyze what it takes to create attractive and livable downtown neighborhoods and provide mechanisms for insuring that infrastructure, open space, and other public facilities and amenities are provided as heights and densities increase.

·        Make the regulations more user-friendly.   Somehow the Office of Planning has managed to draft a new code that is even more opaque and unwieldy than the existing code.  Moreover, because the new code starts from scratch and uses some of same terms but defines them differently, the status and applicability of previous case law is unclear.  

·        Provide mechanisms for effective representation of community interests in development review processes.

Significant policy changes

The proposed new regulations would:


•                 Effectively eliminate single-family residential zones.

•                 Encourage the conversion of houses into apartments.

•                 Allow more commercial activity in residential zones.

•                 Threaten the integrity and viability of neighborhood commercial districts.

•                 Activate alleys by allowing home-based businesses and rental apartments to be located in garages and other out-buildings and by allowing residential development of alley lots of 450 SF. 

•                 Minimize opportunities for public input and give developers and property-owners more control over development and land use decisions.

•                 Rely on generic “conditions” with no enforcement mechanism or penalty for non-compliance rather than on BZA review and project-specific requirements.

•                 Eliminate the ability to create overlays; impose one-size-fits-all policies citywide.

•                 Deliberately make it more difficult and expensive for people who live in the city to own a car.

•                 Treat every area within one-half mile of a Metro station the same with respect to parking requirements -- regardless of existing conditions.

•                 Significantly expand “downtown” to encourage maximum heights and densities in areas beyond the city center.