Showing posts with label Tregoning. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Tregoning. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 11, 2014

The Height Act is back in play

So much for Home Rule -- Tregoning's gone, Gray's disgraced, both the Council and public opinion polling came out strongly opposed to changes in the HBA, but Issa keeps pressing the issue.  And Eleanor Holmes Norton, whose office disclaimed any knowledge of the bill yesterday, is the co-sponsor.  

The text of the bill is available here.


[[Note that NCPC proposed communal recreational use for rooftop structures, but the bill would allow these penthouses to be private residential space.]] 

And here is WBJ's coverage:  

Updated: Mar 11, 2014, 11:30am EDT
House panel to weigh change to D.C. Height Act
Daniel J. Sernovitz
Staff Reporter- Washington Business Journal

House lawmakers are slated to consider making the first change in more than a century to the federal law that caps building heights in D.C.

The proposed change, which would allow uses like restaurants in the penthouse areas of certain buildings, wouldn't result in Manhattan-style skyscrapers in the District. But its passage could be an indication Congress is open to additional changes to the Height of Buildings Act of 1910 following a heated debate of the subject last fall.

The bill is slated to be considered by the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, chaired by Rep. Darrell Issa, R-Calif., on Wednesday. Issa has said he believes the measure is  the first step in a larger debate around the Height Act and has urged the District and National Capital Planning Commission to consider other potential amendments to the law. If it passes the committee level, the bill would need to be approved by the full House and Senate and signed by the president before it can become law.

The proposed bill,  based in part on a recommendation from the NCPC and one of the least controversial parts of the height debate, changes the 1910 law by  permitting "human occupancy" in the penthouse space of buildings as long as those spaces are no taller one story or 20 feet or less above a building's roof. Building owners have typically used those spaces for mechanical equipment. In recommending the change, the NCPC said those spaces could be used as public amenities and generate additional revenue for their owners while not substantially impacting D.C.'s skyline.

Monday, March 10, 2014

Zoning, post-Tregoning

[Originally published in the February 16, 2014 edition of The Mail.  Since then, the Zoning Commission has added two public hearings and extended the deadline for submission of written comments to April 25th at 3 pm.]

It was heartening to hear last week that the Zoning Commission has extended the comment period on the proposed new zoning code until April 17th.  Since November, when public hearings on the draft code started in earnest, what we’ve seen is a series of concerns being raised by residents of neighborhoods across the city.   And I think what we’re learning is that it was a serious mistake to do a wholesale rewrite rather than to amend the existing code.   Burying a series of significant policy changes in a virtually unreadable 980 page text is recipe for poor decision-making.  We need issue-by-issue consideration (which, in some cases, will mean neighborhood-by-neighborhood analysis) of proposed changes in order to evaluate whether they take us closer to (or farther away from) where we as a city want to be. 

The major obstacle to this kind of deliberative approach has been the Zoning Commission’s reliance on the Office of Planning.  On the one hand, that’s a structural problem – e.g. the Office of Planning serves as the experts that vet the Office of Planning’s own work.  And if the Zoning Commission decides that it wants to see that work done better or differently, it has to rely on the Office of Planning to fix what’s broken.  But this structural problem has been aggravated by the dogmatism and, frankly, the belligerence of the Office of Planning under the leadership of Harriet Tregoning. 

Fortunately, that last obstacle is about to be removed.    Weeks after having lost the Height Act battle and a few days before Bill de Blasio would announce he’d chosen someone else to head NYC’s planning department, Tregoning fled to a job with the feds, rather than go down with the sinking ship that is the zoning rewrite effort.  It’s a wise -- probably essential -- career move on her part.  As long as she doesn’t have to get the new code passed or be held responsible for its implementation, Tregoning can claim kudos for her visionary leadership.  And when, quite predictably, her vision doesn’t translate into reality well, that’ll be someone else’s fault.    Shades of Gabe Klein, Scott Kubly and the streetcar system.  Or, for that matter, Michelle Rhee and DCPS.
   
At any rate, our challenge now is to take a fresh look both at our zoning code and at what we want from our next Director of Planning.   These are timely questions to raise during this Mayoral election season.

In essence, zoning is about how much of what belongs where.  The answer that Tregoning’s Office of Planning has proposed in this new code is “more of everything, everywhere.”  This approach represents an abdication of responsibility for planning the city’s growth, as well as the abandonment of zoning as a tool for balancing the interests of neighboring property owners and for taming or channeling market forces.   

Outreach on the proposed new code has focused on a few of the latest planning fads – accessory apartments, corner stores, and the reduction or elimination of on-site parking requirements. These issues are, essentially, sideshows -- distracting attention away from both the sizeable giveaways in the newly expanded downtown and the Office of Planning’s failure to address the most important challenges -- affordability, uneven development, retention of new residents, and a series of quality of life issues – we face as a city.


What we need is a citywide discussion about how and where we grow, conducted by a Planning Director who listens to, learns from, and respects the people who live here.  Someone who is a fundamentally a problem-solver, who will appreciate what’s special about our city and recognize what we want to preserve, but who is also willing and able to initiate the long-term efforts necessary to address our most enduring problems.  We’re not going to attract anyone with those qualities or ambitions if their first job will be the unenviable task of implementing a poorly-conceived and badly-drafted new zoning code.